Best Italian Restaurants in Buffalo

$$

Chef's Restaurant on Seneca Street has earned a devoted following among Buffalo locals and visitors alike, with over 3,600 glowing reviews praising its welcoming atmosphere and diverse menu offerings. This beloved neighborhood gem consistently delivers quality dishes across various cuisines at wallet-friendly prices, making it a reliable choice for any craving. Arrive early during peak hours to snag a table, as its stellar reputation often draws crowds looking for that perfect combination of great food and genuine hospitality.

291 Seneca St, Buffalo, NY 14204, USA

View Map Website

$$

This beloved Blasdell institution has earned its stellar reputation through decades of serving generous portions and classic comfort food in a warm, family-friendly atmosphere that doubles as both neighborhood gem and special occasion destination. With nearly 2,700 glowing reviews, diners consistently praise the consistently excellent food quality, attentive service, and welcoming vibe that keeps locals and visitors returning. Make reservations ahead, especially for weekend dinners, as this popular spot fills up quickly with families and groups celebrating everything from casual nights out to milestone events.

3785 South Park Ave, Blasdell, NY 14219, USA

View Map Website

$$

Despite its name suggesting Italian fare, Mulberry Italian Ristorante actually serves various cuisines, creating a diverse dining experience that has earned an impressive 4.7-star rating from nearly 2,500 satisfied diners. This Lackawanna gem clearly delivers on both quality and variety, making it a reliable choice for groups with different tastes or travelers seeking something beyond typical Italian dishes. With such consistently high ratings, reservations are likely recommended, especially during weekend dinner hours when locals and visitors alike flock to this popular neighborhood spot.

64 Jackson Ave, Lackawanna, NY 14218, USA

View Map Website

$$

La Bella Sicilia has earned a devoted following among Buffalo diners, with over 2,400 reviewers praising its welcoming atmosphere and consistently satisfying meals that span multiple cuisines. This neighborhood gem clearly delivers on both quality and value, as evidenced by its impressive 4.5-star rating from such a large number of guests. Make reservations if possible, especially for weekend dinners, as this popular spot tends to fill up quickly with both locals and visitors seeking a reliable dining experience.

2909 Genesee St, Buffalo, NY 14225, USA

View Map Website

$$$

This beloved Williamsville gem combines the warmth of Sicilian hospitality with perfectly prepared steaks, creating an atmosphere that feels both upscale and welcoming. With an impressive 4.6-star rating from nearly 1,500 diners, Giancarlo's has clearly mastered the art of delivering consistently exceptional food and service that keeps locals and visitors coming back. Make reservations ahead of time, especially for weekend dinners, as this popular spot fills up quickly with diners eager to experience their renowned Italian-American fusion.

5110 Main St Ste 125, Williamsville, NY 14221, USA

View Map Website

$$

Osteria 166 on Franklin Street has earned a devoted following with its welcoming atmosphere and diverse menu that keeps both locals and visitors coming back for more. With an impressive 4.5-star rating from nearly 900 reviews, this neighborhood gem clearly delivers consistent quality and service that exceeds expectations. Make reservations if possible, as this popular spot tends to fill up, especially during weekend dinner hours when the cozy dining room buzzes with happy diners.

166 Franklin St, Buffalo, NY 14202, USA

View Map Website

$$

This beloved Buffalo neighborhood bar on Hertel Avenue has earned an impressive 4.7-star rating from nearly 750 reviews, making it a clear local favorite that consistently delivers on both atmosphere and quality. Travelers rave about Lombardo's welcoming vibe and solid bar fare that keeps both locals and visitors coming back for more. With such strong ratings, expect it to get busy during peak evening hours, so consider stopping by earlier in the day for a more relaxed experience.

1198 Hertel Ave, Buffalo, NY 14216, USA

View Map Website